Project Hail Mary (2026) · ★★★½ · Watched March 29, 2026 · Rewatch
A lovingly crafted piece of sci-fi spectacle that made me cry several times.
Is it basically a guy and his dog? Yes. Admittedly, I’m predisposed to liking it based on that fact alone. Ryland at his loneliest felt relatable and the void Rocky filled in his existence reminded me of my relationship with my dog Alfie (He passed away in 2023). Our time together included so many struggles, including prolonged isolation during the first few months of lockdown in 2020. I couldn’t help but be moved by two distinct beings finding ways to bridge communication gaps, forge a lasting bond, and save their respective planets.
The movie’s strengths are directly connected to its limitations. In our current world, it’s unfathomable that governments would work together to address the astrophage problem. It’s also hard to imagine a middle school science teacher ending up on the mission in the first place. This is where the movie asks us to apply hope and optimism. The teacher solves the problem after befriending a completely non-hostile being in deep space.
The stakes feel minimized by how much of the logistics go relatively well on paper. Obstacles are there to move the story along but the idea that things will work out in the end never really feels threatened. It’s the experience of actually watching the movie and feeling its handmade charm that unlocks its sense of wonder. Ryan Gosling’s pure charisma, a mostly practical and strikingly rendered rock alien puppet, and consistent bursts of comedy with sprinkles of humanity make this a fun watch that builds nicely to its emotional highs and lows.
What’s ultimately at the heart of the story is dark and sometimes a bit confusing given the movie’s elegant avoidance of the rougher stuff. For example, how is Ryland Grace without a single connection on earth when he is literally Ryan Gosling in a perfectly fitting sweater with slutty little glasses? How are the world’s leaders able to sit and exchange punchy dialogue about the reproduction of astrophage (by repeating lines back to Ryland like “Whoomp, there it is?”) when the planet is dying?
Lord and Miller clearly considered questions like these and responded by making the warmer aspects of the story much more prominent. The movie is ultimately structured around facilitating Ryland’s connection with Rocky so they can engage in scientific hijinks that make for great set pieces. Those bits of spectacle are punctuated by dalliances with deeper questions any screenplay would struggle to contain. Everything looks and sounds great and just about every emotional beat works. Somewhere in there Sandra Hüller does an amazing karaoke rendition of “Sign of the Times” and you see glimpses of how the movie could have been truly profound. In ways both relieving and disappointing, it simply isn’t going for that.
I will always enjoy watching and crying along to Grace and Rocky’s journey. It was also nice to be able to share this with loved ones at a 70mm IMAX screening.